« Conflit israélo-arabe » : différence entre les versions
From Liberpédia
Turion (discussion | contribs) |
Turion (discussion | contribs) |
||
| Line 22: | Line 22: | ||
: ... Zionism had succeeded in carving out a European Jewish State, over Arab territory in the Middle East. | : ... Zionism had succeeded in carving out a European Jewish State, over Arab territory in the Middle East. | ||
:... Historians are wont to describe the ensuing war as an invasion of Israel by the Arab states, heroically rebuffed by Israel, but since all of the fighting took place on Arab territory, this interpretation is clearly incorrect. | |||
:: [[Rothbard]], [https://mises.org/library/war-guilt-middle-east War Guilt in the Middle East] | :: [[Rothbard]], [https://mises.org/library/war-guilt-middle-east War Guilt in the Middle East] | ||
Revision as of 21 July 2018 à 13:55
Rappels historiques
http://liberpedia.net/t/Short_history_of_israel.pdf
Propriété privée
- Propriété privée et non collective
Débats
Rothbard
- The British, in return for mobilizing the Arab peoples against their oppressors of imperial Turkey, promised the Arabs their independence when the war was over. But, at the same time, the British government, with characteristic double-dealing, was promising Arab Palestine as a « National Home » for organized Zionism. These promises were not on the same moral plane: for in the former case, the Arabs were being promised their own land freed from Turkish domination; and in the latter, world Zionism was being promised a land most emphatically not its own.
- ... Zionism had succeeded in carving out a European Jewish State, over Arab territory in the Middle East.
- ... Historians are wont to describe the ensuing war as an invasion of Israel by the Arab states, heroically rebuffed by Israel, but since all of the fighting took place on Arab territory, this interpretation is clearly incorrect.
Exemple typique de raisonnment nationaliste, collectiviste, par propriété collective.
- The UN agreement had provided (a) that Jerusalem be internationalized under UN
rule, and (b) that there be an economic union between the new Jewish and Arab Palestine states. These were the basic conditions under which the UN approved partition. Both were promptly and brusquely disregarded by Israel--thus launching an escalating series of aggressions against the Arabs of the Middle East.
https://thejewishlibertarian.files.wordpress.com/2016/07/israel-rothbard-defense.pdf
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ET3MkT1QTg0&feature=youtu.be&t=3594
http://reason.com/archives/2014/08/10/can-moshe-feiglin-reconcile-libertariani/
